How Hong Kong tycoon Li Ka-shing went from friend of China to punching bag

HONG KONG: In January of 1993, an ambitious Chinese Communist Party boss, a 39-year-old official with chubby cheeks and a mop of black hair, visited Hong Kong.

He was seeking out the citys rich among the shimmering skyscrapers, hoping to secure investment in Fuzhou, the second-tier city he ran in mainland China. His name was Xi Jinping.

Advertisement

Advertisement

That August, Xi received a guest back home. Hong Kongs most famous tycoon, Li Ka-shing, known locally as “superman” for his business acumen, had come to town. A photograph from the event shows Xi grinning as he walked beside Li, who held a bouquet of flowers in his hand. In the background, a long banner hung with the message to “warmly welcome” Li Ka-shing.

During those days, in the aftermath of the 1989 Tiananmen incident, Beijing was desperate to fire up a languishing economy. National leaders and provincial potentates were courting Li for his cash and the star power his name brought to development projects on the mainland. That time has passed.

Xi is now the leader of a rich and rising power that controls Hong Kong. Instead of feting the 91-year-old businessman, Beijing has harangued him for failing to deliver in the rebellious city.

When the Party was looking for a chorus of influential voices to counter the protests that began this summer, Li offered only even-handed pleas for restraint. In an online video of comments he made at a monastery, Li asked that the leadership show “humanity” when dealing with young protesters.

Advertisement

Advertisement

READ: Hong Kong tycoon Li Ka-shing urges love, not violence, in first protest comments

The response was brutal. The Partys central legal affairs commission in Beijing publicly accused Li of “harboring criminality” and “watching Hong Kong slip into the abyss". A pro-Beijing trade union leader in Hong Kong posted a Facebook item mocking him as the “king of cockroaches” with an image that pasted Lis head atop a picture of a fat insect.

“In the world of social media, some people are hard at work in sowing toxic doubts and disinformation to undermine trust,” Li said in a written response to questions from Reuters. “It is hard not to be drawn into controversies these times.”

As the Beijing-backed government of Hong Kong cracks down on the demonstrators in the streets, there is another tightening of the leash happening, mostly behind the scenes: Chinas efforts to throttle the power of Hong Kongs tycoons.

Li and other tycoons have long held dominion over Hong Kong, tracing its post-World War II economic rise through manufacturing, real estate and finance. But the ascent of Xi Jinping, who became General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party in 2012, has fundamentally altered the status quo.

Xi is a leader who “thinks that he is like the emperor,” said Willy Lam Wo-lap, a veteran observer of elite Beijing politics at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. “So, he thinks that Hong Kong business people should definitely profess undying loyalty to the emperor, to Xi Jinping.”

The vilification of the citys preeminent capitalist was a rare public display of the new power dynamic, businessmen and analysts say. It sent a clear message that Li and his fellow Hong Kong tycoons must toe the line and unequivocally condemn the protests, which present the most serious challenge to Communist Party rule since Tiananmen.

The now-scrapped legislation that sparked the recent unrest would have allowed for extraditions from Hong Kong to mainland China. It also provided an avenue for the seizure of assets, according to a statement by the Hong Kong Bar Association. That could have exposed the citys tycoons to the same fate as wealthy mainlanders who have been stripped of assets in Xis anti-corruption drive.

Shortly after protests over the Bill escalated in early June, some wealthy Hong Kongers began moving money outside of the region or setting up accounts that would allow them to do so, according to six private bankers whose institutions collectively handle hundreds of billions of dollars in assets.

Reuters spoke with half a dozen people, including current Li executives, who have had personal relationships with the property mogul or worked alongside him over his career. Li stepped down last year and was succeeded by his eldest son as chairman of his two main companies but remains the biggest shareholder.

Chinas foreign ministry declined to answer questions from Reuters. The Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office did not respond to a request for comment.

RISK OF OFFENDING

For all the vitriol aimed at Li in recent months, this was not a sudden split. Before protests convulsed Hong Kong, he was already loosening his economic ties to China.

At the start of this century, his flagship Hutchison Whampoa Ltd got much of its money from Hong Kong and the mainland: 56 per cent of earnings before interest and taxes. Last year that figure at his current flagship firm was 14 per cent.

Since 2015, Li's corporate empire has been involved with more than US$70 billion in acquisitions globally. Less than US$1 billion of that was in Hong Kong and mainland China, according to a Reuters analysis of Lis deals worth US$500 million or more.

Asked about those numbers, a spokesperson for Li said that as Hutchison Whampoa sought large acquisitions overseas in the late 1990s and early 2000s, "the diversification changed the geographical proportions, but we are nevertheless growing in the mainland and in Hong Kong".

In addition, the spokesperson said, a 2015 reorganisation of the group brought down the proportion of earnings from the region for the current flagship.

Shifting large business interests out of Chinas immediate orbit carries the risk of offending mainland officials, especially as Beijing exerts greater control of Hong Kong, said Simon Murray, a former managing director at Lis sprawling corporate operation who has known the billionaire for decades.

“Everybody who is anybody at all in Hong Kong has got one eye on how the mainland sees that,” he said. “And youve got to build your bridges with them, otherwise they could confiscate.”

READ: Hong Kong's richest man Li Ka-shing donates HK$1 billion to support local businesses

For Li, a billionaire in his autumnal years, the tensions with Beijing mark a dramatic turn.

For decades, he enjoyed a position of eminence under Deng Xiaoping and then Jiang Zemin – the two men who led China from the late 1970s to the early 2000s. Li was on committees that drafted Hong Kongs Basic Law, the mini-constitution governing the city since it was handed to Beijing by the British, and on a body that selected its first government.

Lis entire life has been framed by the swings of history in Hong Kong and, looming on its edge, mainland China. He was born in 1928 in the river city of Chaozhou, a place known for its local Chinese opera and embroidery work. When he was a child, the southern Chinese city was a target for Japanese bombing runs. He quit school as a 12-year-old boy and his family fled south down the coast to Hong Kong, then a British colony.

Hong Kong fell to the Japanese in 1941. During that occupation, there were food shortages, malnutrition and disease. Lis father died from tuberculosis not long after they arrived. His company biography describes what came next: “Before he was 15, Mr. Li had to shoulder the responsibility of providing for his family and found a job in a plastics trading company where he labored 16 hours a day."

During a 1998 interview with public broadcaster Radio Television Hong Kong, Li spoke of his mixed feelings when he went back to the mainland in 1978 for the first time in decades. Hed made a fortune in Hong Kong building his way from manufacturing to real estate to finance. The next year, he became the first Hong Kong Chinese investor to take control of one of the British “hongs”, the great trading houses that accompanied colonial rule from the 19th century.

But looking at his motherland, newly emerged from the chaos of Mao Zedongs rule, Li said he hesitated to invest. “I was afraid that people might say Li had come to exploit,” he said in the interview.

Lis doubts about mainland control of Hong Kong appear to be longstanding. Britains conversation with China about the future handover of Hong Kong began heating up in the 1980s. Even back then, Murray said, Li discussed his anxiety about the financial future of his corporate empire.

Murray said that Li asked him to “go over to the UK and find a nice company for us to put some money in.”

That led to Li buying up a stake of more than 4 per cent in Pearson Plc, a British conglomerate, in an early foray into Western markets that brought wider attention. Murray recalled: “It was on the front page of every bloody newspaper.”

Asked about the tycoons concerns at the time, Lis spokesman said: “Anyone, especially if one is leading a company with other shareholders, has to have a degree of paranoia as it is part of responsible leadership. The Chinese a traditional saying: 生於憂患，死於安樂, strive in hard times, perish in contentment'. A certain degree of paranoia prevents the reverse case happening.”

'LIKE A BUDDHA'

After Xi Jinping's visit to Hong Kong in 1993, Li was given the celebrity welcome in Fuzhou, the provincial city Xi then oversaw. The billionaire, who was involved in a redevelopment project there, attended a groundbreaking ceremony with Xi where they laid a foundation stone, according to local media reports.

“It was like a Buddha came to town to build a temple,” said Ruan Yisan, an architecture professor in Shanghai acclaimed for his historical preservation projects who opposed the development. “Officials thought he could do magic here and change the city in a dramatic way.”

At the time, Li had outsized impact in China. In September of 1997, about two months after the handover of Hong Kong, China was on the verge of its largest-ever stock offering, a state-owned telecommunications company preparing to list on the Hong Kong and New York exchanges. At the last minute, a group of Hong Kong tycoons backing the listing of China Telecom got spooked by a financial crisis roiling the region. They said they wanted to renegotiate an agreement that required them to hold their stakes for a year, or drop out completely. It was just weeks before the listing went to market.

Li beckoned a group of Chinese bureaucrats and bankers to his Hong Kong office. He told them that he had signed a contract and would abide by it, according to a banker who was in the room.

Then, the Chinese banker said, the billionaire went one step further: He offered to buy a larger stake if necessary. Li helped salvage the deal, which became a template for a flood of state-owned Chinese companies raising billions of dollars through public listings.

It was the sort of moment that made Li, with his trademark large black-framed glasses, Hong Kongs most fabled businessman.

“Mr Li is not a man to break an agreement easily,” the spokesman for the billionaire said.

Inside China, though, even Li found that the opaque nature of doing business could mean problems, according to those who have worked with him and his own public remarks.

In the public broadcaster interview, Li detailed his frustrations with building Oriental Plaza. A sprawling development in the heart of Beijing, the project faced political wrangling and loud public disagreement about its size as it went up in the 1990s. His Chinese partners, he said, gained a 40 per cent share of the project, up from an initial 10 per cent or so. Li said he had learned a lesson.

“In a political and cultural centre like Beijing, one has to put business and economics in a lesser position,” he said. “Although Ive run into all sorts of trouble, I now have a better understanding of China.”

XI'S MESSAGE

After Xi took power, Beijing adopted a harder line toward Hong Kong. In a 2014 white paper, Beijing said the autonomy the city enjoys was not a given but, instead, contingent on the permission of the central leadership. And Li himself began facing criticism from Chinese state media.

During late 2014 and early 2015, Li folded his Hong Kong-registered Hutchison Whampoa and another company into firms incorporated in the Cayman Islands. Lis team says the changes were part of a “streamlining and succession plan".

In September 2015, in the wake of reports of those moves, Li was excoriated by mainland media outlets as insufficiently patriotic. The Peoples Daily, the main mouthpiece of the Communist Party, posted a commentary on social media saying that Li was happy to “enjoy the benefits when things are good” but couldnt be counted on in tough times.

Li released a statement affirming his support of Beijings leadership, adding: “The Company, as always, will continue to look for investment opportunities around the world, including mainland China.”

In that period, though, companies under Lis control were plowing billions of dollars into stakes of firms abroad while pulling back in Hong Kong and on the mainland. That trend hasnt slowed.

Since 2015, Lis companies have been involved in acquisitions abroad worth more than US$70 billion, in places like Canada, Italy and Australia. In that same period, he participated in just one acquisRead More – Source